Cognate Set 1213 – Meaning: stick

IE-CoR reference form:
*pal-
IE-CoR reference language:
Proto-Slavic
Ideophonic:
no
Parallel derivation:
no
Justification:
No certain etymology outside of Slavic (Derksen 2008:390; cf. Vasmer 1986-1987 3:191-193, Rejzek 2001:441-443, Boryś 2005:408-409, Bezlaj 1977-2005 3:5 for various proposals and further discussion).
Found in clades:
Slavic
Revised by:
Lechosław Jocz, Matthew Scarborough
Found in 1 clade by 9 lexemes.
Language Lexeme Native script Phonetic Phonemic Notes
97   Russian papka палка ˈpɑ̈ɫkɐ ˈpalka
85   Slovene palica ˈpɑ̈̀ːlitsɑ̈ ˈpàːlitsa
78   Old Church Slavonic palica палица pɑlitsʲa palitsa There are quite many alternative lexemes: 'жрьдь, посоха, дрьколь, дрѫгъ, жьзлъ'. However, some of them are pretty rare attested in the Canon ('дрѫгъ' and 'посоха' appear only once). Farther, they all are attested in more specific meanings like 'club, bar, sceptre'. 'палица' seems to be the best lexeme for the Swadesh term.
99   Ukrainian palicâ палиця ˈpɑ̈ɫɪtsʲɐ ˈpalɪtsʲa An alternative lexeme is 'кий', which has, however, a restricted usage and more specialized meaning in the contemporary language.
91   Slovak palica ˈpɑ̈litsɑ̈ ˈpalitsa
98   Belarusian palka палка ˈpɑ̈ɫkɑ̈ ˈpalka
100   Rusyn pálɪc′a ˈpɑ̈lɪtsʲɑ̈ ˈpalɪtsʲa There are many synonyms: 'pʹalka' (with the same root), 'kọštúr', 'buk' and 'kopáč'.
86   Slovene: Kostel palica ˈpɑ̈ːlʲtsɑ̈ ˈpaːʎtsa
84   Slovene: Early Modern paliza
References
  • Bezlaj, France: 3: 5
    PS *pala (along with *palica, *palŭka, *palĭ) has some possible explanations. Most probably it is related to PS palĭcĭ 'thick finger'. I has been also explainded as derived from PIE *(s)p(ʰ)el- 'chop, bang' or compared to *paliti 'burn'.
  • Boryś, W.: 408-409
    PS *pala 'thick stick' (with diminutives *palŭka and *palica) is probably derived from PIE *pōlo- 'thick', see also palec ['finger' < 'thoe, thumb']. Cf. Latin pollex 'thumb', polleō, pollēre 'be strong'.<br> Polish pal 'pole' is a loanword from Middle High German pfâl.
  • Derksen, Rick: 390
    S.v. Proto-Slavic *palica 'stick, staff' "The obvious connection with forms containing a root *pol- (e.g. *polìca) forces us to reconstruct a lengthened grade *pōl- for *palica. This is not in agreement with the accentual evidence, however. The etymology of the root is unclear."
  • Rejzek, Jiří: 441-443
    The etymology of PS *palica is not entirely clear.<br> It can be related to pálit 'bounce' that is related to Latin pellere 'drive away, kill, beat' and maybe also to Old Indich sphāláyati 'clash, beat'. Then it would be derived from PIE *(s)pel- 'beat'. In Slavic, it has been contaminated with pálit 'glow, burn'. It is also possible that both verbs have a common origin.<br> Another hypothesis links PS *palica to PS *paliti 'glow, burn' (derived from PIE *pel-/*pol-). The semantic motivatition were that sticks as tools were seared over the fire to get durable.<br> If the meaning of PS *palica was originally 'thick stick', it could be also compared with PS *palŭ that is derived from PIE *pōlo- 'thick', cf. palec ['toe, thumb'].
  • Vasmer, Max: 3: 191-193
    Russian palka (along with Serbo-Croat palica, Slovene palica, Polish pałka etc.) is most probably not a loanword from Old High German pfâl 'pal' (which is, in turn, a borrowing from Latin pāllus). It is maybe related to Old High German spaltan 'split', Old Indic spháṭati 'split', spuṭáti 'tear' etc. It is also rather unrelated to palec ['finger'].<br> Russian palec ['finger'] (cf. also Polish palec, Czech palec, Upper Sorbian palc etc.) is derived from PS *palŭ (cf. Russian bespalyj, šestipalyj). It is usually linked to Latin pollex 'thumb, big toe'. It can be further related to New Persian pālidan 'look for' and Old High German fuolen 'feel'.<br> [Cf. also for a summary of other hypotheses.]
  • de Vaan, Michiel: 478
    "The alleged connection with CS palьcь [...] < PSl. *palьcь < *pōl- does not explain Latin pollex. Meier-Brügger 1990 proposes to explain pollex from *por-likʰ-s 'which is licked over' to the root *leiɡ́ʰ- 'to lick' (see Lat. linɡō)."