Cognate Set 1114 – Meaning: bone

IE-CoR reference form:
*kost-
IE-CoR reference language:
Proto-Slavic
Ideophonic:
no
Parallel derivation:
no
Proposed as cognate to:
*h₂ost- [Proto-Indo-European] scale: 0
Justification:
Sometimes considered with cognate with PIE *h₂ost- in cognate set 519 but the details remain unclear (cf. Derksen 2008:239, ESSJa 11:167-173 for further discussion). This cognate set is otherwise restricted to Slavic.
Found in clades:
Slavic
Revised by:
Matthew Scarborough, Lechosław Jocz
Found in 1 clade by 19 lexemes.
Language Lexeme Native script Phonetic Phonemic Notes
79   Bulgarian kost кост kɔst kost
98   Belarusian kosc′ косць kɔsʲtsʲ kosʲtsʲ An alternative form is a diminutive 'костка' with meaning 'single bone'.
93   Czech kost kɔst kost
95   Sorbian: Lower kósć kɛstɕ, kɘ̟stɕ kostɕ
94   Sorbian: Upper kósć kʊstʃ kʊstʃ
80   Macedonian koska коска ˈko̞skɑ̈ ˈkoska
88   Polish kość kɔɕtɕ koɕtɕ
97   Russian kost' кость kɔsʲtsʲ kostʲ
83   Serbo-Croat kost kô̞ːst kôːst
91   Slovak kosť kɔsc kosc
85   Slovene kost kóːst kóːst
99   Ukrainian kìstka кістка ˈkʲistkɐ ˈkistka Formally/historically a diminutive. A non-diminutive form 'кість' is used too, but the form 'кістка' is the main form.
78   Old Church Slavonic kostĭ кость kɔstɪ̆ kostɪ
90   Polabian ťüst cyst cyst
87   Old Polish kość kɔɕtɕ koɕtɕ An alternative lexeme could be 'gnat'. However it tends to refer especially to 'shin bone'.
92   Old Czech kost kɔsc kostj
100   Rusyn k′ḯska ˈkʲi̞ʂkɑ̈ ˈki̞ʂka
86   Slovene: Kostel kost ˈko̝ːst ˈko̝ːst
84   Slovene: Early Modern kúſt
References
  • Bezlaj, France: 2: 71
    The Slavic lexeme has no clear parallels in IE. It is usually linked to Latin os, ossis, Old Indic ásthi, Greek ὀστέον etc. The initial k- is explained as a result of a contamination (cf. Latin costa 'rib').
  • Boryś, W.: 253
    The Slavic lexeme is related to PIE *h₃est-. The irregular k- is probably due to a contamination with another root (maybe related to Latin costa).
  • Derksen, Rick: 239
    S.v. Proto-Slavic *kôstь 'bone' (ESSJa XI 167-173). "The relationship with the otherwise isolated Lat. costa ‘rib’ seems quite possible. An interesting hypothesis is to regard the *k of *kȏstь as the reflex of the initial laryngeal of PIE *h₂ost- ‘bone’, cf. Skt. ásthi, Gk. ὀστέον, in an Indo-European substratum language (cf. Kortlandt 1997b: 47, where the option is dismissed, however). Meillet (e.g. 1921, Ét. II: 262) regards the *k as a prefix. If the root is *h₂ost-, we are probably dealing with an original neuter *kosti."
  • Georgiev, V. and Račeva, M. and Todorov, T. and Durdianov, I.: 2: 661-663
    The lexeme is related to Latin costa 'rib'. The hypotheses about a relationship to Latin os 'bone' etc. (assuming a prefix *k- or a metathesis from *osthr̥k-) is improbable.
  • Jocz, Lechosław:
    There is no clear further etymology of the Slavic lexeme. All hypotheses assuming a relationship to PIE *h₃est- fail to explain the initial k- in a convincing way. Other proposed cognates are etymologically unclear themselves. The proposed relationship to PIE *kes- seems to lack an entirely convincing semantic motivation.
  • Kortlandt, Frederik: 47
  • Meillet, Antoine: 1-2
  • Meillet, Antoine: II:262
  • Mel'ničuk, O.: 2: 450
    The lexeme is related to Slavic *kositi and *česati [PIE *kes-]. The hypotheses about a relationship to Latin costa 'rib' or Latin os 'bone' etc. are not convincing.
  • Rejzek, Jiří: 304
    The Slavic lexeme is usually linked to Latin os etc. (PIE *h₃est-). However, k- needs an explanation then. Most probably it is a result of a contamination (cf. Latin costa 'rib' or PIE *kes-).
  • Schuster-Šewc, H.: 633-634
    It is usually assumed to be related to Latin os, ossis 'bone'. The initial k- is explained as a prefix or as a special reflex of the initial laryngal. In fact, we deal here most probably with two different etymona. The Slavic lexeme is related to Latin costa 'rib'. PIE *kos-t- [PIE *kes-] 'sharp, cutting, outstanding'.
  • Skok, Petar: 2: 163-164
    There is no certain etymology.
  • Snoj, Marko:
    PIE *h₂osti-. The Slavic lexeme is related to Old Indic ásthi- ‛bone’, Albanian asht, Latin os, Hittite ḫaštāi-. The initial k- is probably due to a contamination with a currently lost word related to Latin costa 'rib'. A simmilar irregular k- is found in Slavic *koza 'goat'.
  • Trubačev, O. N.: 11: 167-173, 12: 19-21
    PS ostĭ 'awn, fishbone' is most probably related to PIE root for 'sharp' [PIE *h₂ek̑-], and not to PIE root for 'bone' [PIE *h₃est-] but the latter hypothesis is also reasonable. Generally, Slavic *kostĭ and *ostĭ seem to be unrelated. The Latin word costa 'rib' is isolated and its etymology remains unclear. For a comparison with the Slavic lexeme additional closer cognates are necessary. The same applies to Old Indic kāṣṭhá- 'log'. All existing hypotheses linking the Slavic lexeme to Latin os, ossis etc. [PIE *h₃est-] (k- as prefix, borrowing from a substrate IE language, k- as prothesis disposing the hiatus in nominal phrases, metathesis of *osthr̥k or *ostĭka, contamination with other lexemes/roots) are unconvincing. The PS word *koza 'goat' (with analogues like Old Indic ajá or Lithuanian ožỹs) is not a further example for the 'irregular initial k-' in Slavic. This lexeme is most probably a loan from Altaic and the variation in the onset has its sources there (the variation is attested in Turkic). The Slavic lexeme is derived from PIE *kes- with a suffix *-to- (*kos-to-). The original meaning were 'bone protruding from under the skin, a dangling thing, a ticking thing'.
  • Vasmer, Max: 2: 349
    It is related to Latin costa 'rib'.
  • de Vaan, Michiel: 140
    S.v. Lat. costa 'rib', de Vaan acknowledges the possibility of deriving the Slavonic forms from PIE *Host- with a singular development of *H > *k, but he rejects the connection with Latin costa. His argument is the existence of Latin os, ossis. Latin costa is thus "an isolated word without etymology".
  • Šanskij, N. and Ivanov, V. and Šanskaâ, T.: 216
    The lexeme is related to Latin costa 'rib'.
  • Šapošnikov, A. K.: 1: 432
    The word is derived from PIE *kes- and related to Latin costa 'rib', Old Indic kastha- 'log' and Albanian kashtë 'straw'.