Cognate Set 852 – Meaning: bad

IE-CoR reference form:
*malo-
IE-CoR reference language:
Proto-Italic
Ideophonic:
no
Parallel derivation:
no
Justification:
Etymology outside of Italic uncertain, cf. Ernout & Meillet 1985:380, de Vaan 2008:360 for a survey of proposed extra-Italic cognates. For the Romance lexemes cf. Meyer-Lübke 1935:429.
Found in clades:
Italic
Revised by:
Matthew Scarborough
Found in 1 clade by 16 lexemes.
Language Lexeme Native script Phonetic Phonemic Notes
141   Catalan mal maɫ mal
136   French mauvais mɔvɛ mɔvɛ
144   Portuguese mau maw maw
134   Sardinian: Logudoro malu ˈmaːlu ˈmaːlu
133   Sardinian: Nuoro malu ˈmaːlu ˈmaːlu
143   Spanish malo ˈmalo ˈmalo
137   Walloon moː moː
124   Latin malus ˈmaɫus ˈmalus gen. malī
146   Oscan mallom Latin alphabet: mallom (acc.sg., TB 5,15, 2), malom (acc.sg.,TB Pocc.185,11) mallud (abl.sg. TB 20), malud (abl.sg., TB 11.)
135   Anglo-Norman malveis
142   Old Spanish malo ˈmalo
128   Neapolitan malamente malaˈmɛntə malaˈmɛntə
138   Old Occitan mau, mala adj: masc, fem
140   Old Catalan mal mal mal
139   Franco-Provençal môvè moˈve moˈve adjective, masculine form; feminine singular = môvéza; feminine plural = môvézé; probably borrowed from French (< mauvais)
145   Portuguese: Brazilian mau
References
  • Ernout, Alfred and Meillet, Antoine: 380
    S.v. Lat. malus 'mauvais, méchant', Etymology uncertain. Appearance of Oscan dolud malud, perum dolom mallom in the Tabula Bantia may give evidence for Proto-Italic *malo-, however this legal phraseology in Oscan may have been borrowed from Latin. Scattered attestation of lexemes such as Old Irish mell 'destruction', Ancient Greek μέλεος 'idle, unhappy', Classical Armenian meł 'sin', Lithuanian mẽlas 'lie', Latv. màlds 'mistake', suggest a possible PIE *mol-o-. Because of the different semantics, however, this connection remains uncertain.
  • Meyer-Lübke, Wilhelm: 429
    S.v. 5263 Lat. malus 'schlecht'.
  • de Vaan, Michiel: 360
    S.v. Lat. malus 'unpleasant, bad', from Proto-Italic *malo- (cf. O mallom, malom [acc.sg.], either from O. *malu̯o-/*mali̯o- or a borrowing from Latin), from PIE *mol-o- 'bad'? (cf. OIr. mell 'destruction', Gk. μέλεος 'idle; unhappy', perh. βλασφημέω 'to slander'; Arm. mel 'sin', Lith. mẽlas 'lie', Latv. màlds 'mistake'. "The etymology given here is proposed by [[Ernout & Meillet 1985](src-316)]. It is semantically fine, but since it concerns a collection of largely isolated words in different IE branches it remains uncertain."